| name | Maureen | |
| country | USA | |
| dolphincheddar@gmail.com | ||
post |
Okay, guestbooks are twelve different types of super fun! You need more awesome questions, I think.
Um, yeah, so I read your comic. I enjoy it. And stuff. Going away now! | |
| DATE | Thursday, June 4th 2009 - 11:53:03 PM | |
| name | Quaxo | |
| country | Canada | |
| quaxo9@hotmail.com | ||
post |
Hi, I just discovered your comic yesterday and read it through - I couldn't help it! The first thing that struck me (strangely enough) were the mouths. You have an amazing talent for faces, nevermind the costuming and backgrounds, but the thing that definitely struck me the most was your ability to get the proper expression in lips and mouths. Your drawing talent coupled with an intriguing story has me in for the long-haul! Thanks so much for sharing your talent! ~ Q | |
| DATE | Thursday, April 23rd 2009 - 09:49:13 PM | |
| name | Greg (Linux Guy From Hell) | |
| country | USA | |
| gldunn@mtu.edu | ||
post |
Dean just pointed out your webcomic to me today, quite awesome Esther. The style is really beautiful and kickass. Anywho, see you on campus | |
| DATE | Saturday, March 28th 2009 - 02:51:21 AM | |
| name | Justin | |
| country | USA | |
post |
Spastic: try "Looking for Group". This comic has not missed an update yet. Very well done and funny as all heck. | |
| DATE | Wednesday, March 18th 2009 - 03:57:38 AM | |
| name | spastic | |
| country | israel | |
post |
seriously, though. what's up with daian's face in panel 1, page 211? is that his mouth, the overly long white strip? it looks like the false hinged mouth of a wooden doll...the art is so good in general i can't quite grasp what's going on there. is it an oversight or am i imagining things?
hannah recommends some good comics, but i do not read HERO. looked for it, couldn't find it - link please? hannah, you are sorely missing out on wayfarer's moon - and regularly updated. right up there with lint, phoenix req and catalyst. feywinds is also very good, but the plot is not moving along lately. once/week updates means side stories take you way off track and each page must be written to precision from the get-go - again, i'd recommend to comic creators to take a lesson from the shadowgirls creators - their art is actually not my favorite, though it's very good - but it's the best written comic in the genre online right now bar none. i love nicole's art, though - i think her thing is she focuses on video games more than fantasy lit or webcomics, which limits her story. same problem with garanos, the author doesn't read fantasy, so her own is littered with plot holes, poor character development, etc. - it is a rare combination that the same person should write and illustrate the story - since webcomics are generally one-person operations with zero profit, they suffer from either poor writing or poor illustration. i think crystal's doing pretty well, but i would call colby purcell the master in the fantasy webcomic genre, followed up by ellerton. | |
| DATE | Thursday, March 5th 2009 - 09:07:47 PM | |
| name | Justin | |
| country | USA | |
post |
Hello Esther, just wanted to say I really enjoy your artwork. Not very often I add a "realistic" webcomic to my list. This is good stuff though! | |
| DATE | Saturday, February 14th 2009 - 04:23:18 AM | |
| name | Hannah | |
| country | USA | |
| sweetcuppincakes@ymail.com | ||
post |
Lovely artwork + exciting, mysterious, potentially romantic storyline = insta-fave :)
You're up there with Lint, The Phoenix Requiem, HERO, and Fey Winds! | |
| DATE | Wednesday, January 28th 2009 - 11:40:04 AM | |
| name | Griffon Girl | |
| country | USA | |
post |
Heya! I've actually been following the comic for awhile, but right I just wanted to tell you...
You have an incredible talent for drawing, writing and story-making. I'm sure if you had critics they would find some nit-picky excuse to say you're horrible. You're not. You're awesome, and I hope you never stop taking joy in using this talent to entertain yourself and others. | |
| DATE | Tuesday, January 27th 2009 - 06:34:45 PM | |
| name | Sheela | |
| country | Denmark | |
post |
Ooooo, lovely comic! Me likey!
And soldierboy has a cruuush!! :D | |
| DATE | Friday, January 23rd 2009 - 05:30:03 PM | |
| name | Gunnr | |
| country | USA | |
| trikt@sbcglobal.net | ||
post |
Ref the dialog on page 206, the plural of "lowlife" is "lowlifes." Counterintuitive, I know, but that's English for you. | |
| DATE | Friday, January 23rd 2009 - 02:42:59 AM | |
| name | BarG | |
| country | USA | |
| stickybar2@sbcglobal.net | ||
post |
Pretty sneaky making us vote to "preview" the next page! | |
| DATE | Friday, January 16th 2009 - 05:08:31 AM | |
| name | amanda | |
| country | us | |
post |
Stumbled onto your comic by accident. I was very glad I stayed! I love your sense of humour. Poor rat! | |
| DATE | Sunday, October 19th 2008 - 07:55:15 PM | |
| name | Faevv | |
| country | New Jersey | |
| willow_the_vampire@hotmail.com | ||
post |
wowz ...... i just started reading this comic and i love it ^_^ you should keep going hehe | |
| DATE | Sunday, October 12th 2008 - 10:13:25 PM | |
| name | Gordon | |
| country | Canada | |
post |
I've just started reading your comic and I love it! | |
| DATE | Tuesday, September 2nd 2008 - 04:11:20 AM | |
| name | Caterina | |
| country | Poland | |
| c_lebiediev@o2.pl | ||
post |
My, I like your style of drawing. I don't know why, but it reminds me of some good old comics in my country... And I really love the story - especially Elei and her determination, but all characters are charming. I can't wait for the updates... And I hope that the story is meant to be long :-) | |
| DATE | Friday, August 1st 2008 - 02:01:57 PM | |
| name | WOMBAT | |
| country | Utah, USA | |
| plausible_deniability5@yahoo.com | ||
post |
Both Kai and Elei look very graceful and wonderfully vulnerable. I like your style of drawing hair. I think the foxes looked too cartoon-ish, and not nearly "wild" enough. My only complaint is the lack of updates, though you should work at your own pace, of course! Your writing and storytelling are superb. Keep up the good work! Thx ;-) | |
| DATE | Thursday, July 10th 2008 - 10:26:20 PM | |
| name | Karen | |
| country | Canada | |
post |
Absolutely beautiful artwork, interesting characters, and a great plot, too! Can't ask for more. | |
| DATE | Thursday, July 10th 2008 - 01:02:10 PM | |
| name | Kaitlin | |
post |
OMG
You are a brilliant writer. And you are the best artist I have seen in years. | |
| DATE | Wednesday, June 4th 2008 - 04:37:33 AM | |
| name | Liz | |
| country | US | |
| ...sorry | ||
| site | http://kazaie.deviantart.com | |
post |
I am in love already! Great comic! | |
| DATE | Saturday, April 19th 2008 - 11:02:11 PM | |
| name | North | |
| country | US | |
| rolandofgilead.aaron@gmail.com | ||
post |
Seriously amazing stuff. Will you ever be releasing this in book format? I'd eat it up like candy. | |
| DATE | Sunday, February 3rd 2008 - 09:09:42 PM | |
| name | aspectre | |
| country | USA | |
post |
Just finished the Prologue, and am seriously IMPRESSED with both your artwork and your story-atmosphere-thus-far.
Obviously haven't read enough to have an opinion about the plot, but you've intrigued me enough to make me wish I had run across this earlier, and to guarantee that I'll continue reading. | |
| DATE | Wednesday, January 23rd 2008 - 05:37:20 AM | |
| name | Calliope | |
| country | USA | |
post |
Hmmm. I'm intrigued. And Crystal, your story is on that perfect borderline between supposition and suspicion - I'm actually rather wary of Elei. Well done.
Searching for epics, Calliope | |
| DATE | Friday, December 14th 2007 - 02:18:49 AM | |
| name | Megan | |
| country | USA | |
| smiles8045@gmail.com | ||
post |
HI, just came over from Tangents. Wonderful comic, great story line. I can't wait to read more. This one is going in the favorites list. | |
| DATE | Wednesday, December 5th 2007 - 03:10:01 PM | |
| name | Numiela | |
| country | Denmark | |
| site | http://www.numiela.deviantart.com | |
post |
Hi there!
Read the comic just now! I really like your style you know, it's quite inspiring! Also nice plot this far. I'll be sure to come back for more :D | |
| DATE | Friday, November 30th 2007 - 02:37:01 AM | |
| name | Lapin | |
| country | Canadaland | |
post |
I've always loved your art, and now I get to look at them all at once. Yay!
The plot is looking good so far. I'm really interested in seeing how it unfolds. | |
| DATE | Wednesday, August 8th 2007 - 05:55:40 PM | |
| name | mindlessdreamer | |
| country | Singapore | |
post |
Great art, especially the way you drew the foxes. :)
D'ya have any plans to publish Catalyst anytime soon? Cause I'll LOVE the own a paper copy. | |
| DATE | Sunday, June 17th 2007 - 04:19:57 AM | |
| name | Jono | |
| country | Aussie Aussie | |
| site | http://jo-no.blogspot.com | |
post |
Hey there! You never told me you drew comics!? Its cool! And the plot is far from cliche. Just a comment bout drawing. Its nice and all already but if you could just draw them in more DETAIL. The folding of the cloths, face lines, hair, wood, metal, all in as much detail as possible, it would bring more depth to your artwork. Less details just makes it more towards the manga style, japanese looking type of art. Not that its bad. Just a suggest and comment. Like it nonetheless.
Cheers! | |
| DATE | Wednesday, April 11th 2007 - 05:25:32 AM | |
| name | Maria | |
| site | http://chandarina.deviantart.com | |
post |
Hello! I just wanted to say I love your art style in the comic! And the plot is really interesting. | |
| DATE | Sunday, April 1st 2007 - 03:07:37 PM | |
| name | Kiddo | |
| site | http://langleyark.com/ark.php | |
post |
It was a wonderful gift, you sneaky little such and such. Beautiful comic and I shall be one of doubtless many Alcarin fangirls now. | |
| DATE | Sunday, December 31st 2006 - 05:56:32 PM | |
| name | tarramint | |
| site | http://tarramint.deviantart.com | |
post |
Hey Crystal! You've got great background and perspective shots in your comic. And you just HAD to stop the prologue at that point...just when we were going to find out what Elei wants! It's great to see it up and running ;) Gives me something to follow when Sarah's is done :P | |
| DATE | Sunday, February 26th 2006 - 08:21:47 AM | |
| name | Crystal | |
post |
Just testing. | |
| DATE | Friday, November 18th 2005 - 05:27:17 AM | |