Dreambook - Sacrilege!

Welcome to my nifty Dreambook, a free guestbook service from New Dream Network and the Webring! If you have a minute, please add your entry to those below by signing my Dreambook!

Want to praise or criticize a story? Want to discuss the third person vs. first person fiction? Want to comment on the site organization or appearance? Discuss! After I recover from the avalanche of criticisms, I will try to respond to all comments, publicly or privately. --Cress, the Editor

Name or Alias:	Winter
About general site, or specific page? :	general
Comments: I'm so glad I found this site - I've been looking for canon-specific slash fic for ages! :) Not that I don't love the TV/Movie adaptation fic, but it's just amazing to read so much brilliantly written work that captures the feel and style of the original - and the site and essays are so lovngly kept. Thank-you!

Name or Alias:	Anna Li
About general site, or specific page? :	general and specific
Comments: I have indulged myself for weeks reading the stories and novels on this site.Thank you for this wonderful website! I like the young and passionate and "bull pup"character of Watson in Prelude, I like the cleverly weaved plots and a sophisticated and morally-bound Watson in Could Fill A Book. But among all, I love the philosophical depth given to the character of Sherlock Holmes in A False Position. I like the way the story ends where it is now, leaving spaces for readers to digest and ponder within and beyond all the possiblity of love, intimacy and sexuality the story offers.

Name or Alias:	Matthew
About general site, or specific page? :	general and specific
Comments: I really like the look of your site! Rex Stout's 'Watson was a Woman?' brought me here, and I must say it is a delightful piece. Thank you!

Name or Alias:	mariden
Homepage URL:	http://mariden.tumblr.com/
About general site, or specific page? :	general
Comments: I really, really love this page and admire you for making it! It's simply brilliant! Thank you so very much! :)

Name or Alias:	James Thompson
About general site, or specific page? :	Who is Watson
Comments: They say that great authors write what they know, and I believe that in Doyle's case, this is true. Doyle studied medicine under Dr. Joseph Bell, even working as his assistant and based much of Holmes on him. Indeed, his deductive powers were so well known that Bell was called in to help investigate the Jack the Ripper case. I think that, as he'd patterned Holmes from Bell, Doyle himself was the basis for Watson. There is even a strong physical resemblance to the Watson most of us picture, as seen in the sole film interveiw that Doyle made. They were both medical men, both writers, and both men of a sensitive and spiritual nature, who admired (and probably sometimes resented) their respective mentors.

Name or Alias:	Amanda
Homepage URL:	http://offensiveagentpie.tumblr.com
About general site, or specific page? :	General
Comments: I can't believe it's taken me so long to leave a comment on this site! I've been visiting and reading this site for ages! I absolutely adore it! Very comprehensive and full of wonderful fics as well as links! Keep up the fantastic work!

Name or Alias:	Cress
Homepage URL:	http://cress4.blogspot.com/
About general site, or specific page? :	thanks everybody
Comments: Thanks for all the recent messages guys. Yes, I've read Rohase Piercy's book and really enjoyed it. I'm glad you enjoyed my ebook. I haven't been able to update the site in a long while, and I'm sorry about that. I'll try to get another chapter on the Madness story sometime soon.

Name or Alias:	SherlockWatson :)
About general site, or specific page? :	Prelude to a Partnership
Comments: Hey there,, wonderful, awesome Miss Cress! :) I just found your website and am so very delighted about its topic. But before I indulge into this slashy Sherlockiana, I wanted to let you know one fact: your novel „Prelude to a Partnership“ is one of my most beloved favourite fics! I got me that e-book of yours some time last year and am happy to reread it every now and then. :) So, I'm going to ravish that website of yours. Btw: have you read “My dearest Holmes“ by Rohase Piercy? Thanks for your writing and everything you do for us poor shlashergirls! ;)

Name or Alias:	chichu
Homepage URL:	http://bgm.tv/user/qiexingqiezhi
About general site, or specific page? :	general
Comments: Say sorry first. As a foreign, my English is very poor. But I love these essays and stories very much. I expect our dear host to bring more surprise for visiters. I don't know whether the use of my words and grammer exact or not. Or how Illiterate it is. I just want to express my admiration. Apology above.

About general site, or specific page? :	Miss Roylott's 'Sacrilege!'
Comments: This fiction is absoloutley great, you can really feel the desoerate heat between Holmes and Watson as they experience eachother's bodies for the first time. I especially loved the line about the restraints being only symbolic and the characters are certainly as true to the book as they can be with such a plot. Thanks for sharing!

Name or Alias:	Waffa
About general site, or specific page? :	general
Comments: This is such an amazing find. I started reading ACD's Sherlock Holmes books as a pre-teen, and always pictured Watson and Holmes as a couple. Now, as an adult, I've remembered that and started binge reading H/W fic voraciously. I have to say that this site is the best collection I've found, and it's awesome to see that it's actually still active, (unlike many other sites out there.) Hell, I may even get back into writing fic and try my hand at some H/W! Thanks for keeping the site awesome.

Name or Alias:	Jacob
About general site, or specific page? :	Susanna Shepherd's "Hidden Depths"
Comments: Oh, wow. First story here that I couldn't resist commenting on, but not simply for the quality--although that's apparent--but for the subject. Holmes's situation in this is heartbreaking. Not only are his affections unrequited, but he was put in the position where they're also consummated. Even for a 'calculating machine' such as Holmes, that play on his emotions must be incredibly painful. The story did not end as one would suspect, with Watson realising his passion for Holmes as the evening progresses; it ends as desperate as it began. So! Kudos to Susanna on a heart-rending fic. Well done, indeed.

Name or Alias:	JAELINNA
Homepage URL:	http://http://translate.googleusercontent.com/translate_c?hl=es&sl=en&u=http://www.hwslash.net/frames.html&prev=/search%3Fq%3DFanfic%252BWatson%252BHolmes%26hl%3Des%26biw%3D1362%26bih%3D529%26prmd%3Divns&rurl=translate.google.cl&usg=ALkJrhgn33yxwTb4eVIvBXkxEw6N4DZxZg
About general site, or specific page? :	general
Comments: AMO LA PAREJA!!!

Name or Alias:	Mary
About general site, or specific page? :	general
Comments: You're amazing. Keep it up!

Name or Alias:	AL
About general site, or specific page? :	Absurdly Simple
Comments: Dear Irene Adler. I don't know if you read the comments on this site, but I have to tell you, yours is the BEST S/W story I've ever read EVER! I want to read it again and again. You are such a wonderful writer!!!!!

Name or Alias:	Riley Goo
About general site, or specific page? :	Magnificent, no¿
Comments: I must confess, I was not optimistic about such a sites credibility in the use of in-characterness, however I was (if you'll excuse my bluntness) quite wow'd by the respectable works in such a repitoire. I am not all fond of obscene or OOC H/W workings. I do enjoy quite extensive lemoning (as every slash fangirl should) though I am rather picky as to how they are written. Sacrilege is a perfect example of my dream come true. ;ß

Name or Alias:	Chatte Noire
About general site, or specific page? :	specific: Cress's sketch, dressmaking
Comments: Personally I encourage the incorporation into the proposed rewrite. The original plot alone does stand on its own but it leaves the reader wanting; it doesn't shine as pretty as it could. A full week of crossdressing for the plot to develop would add that shine and allow for a more natural feel to the end result of the proposed consummation. Altogether I am impressed and delighted with the overall idea. It makes sense for Holmes to perfect at least one feminine disguise for his repertoire. I look forward to any rewrite that may come of this sketch.

Name or Alias:	G-dot
Homepage URL:	http://www.fanfiction.net/u/1229480/
About general site, or specific page? :	'Under the Desk'
Comments: This was marvelous in its characterisation of J. Watson and the way Holmes thought of the whole affair with sex with Watson and 'why people killed each other for it' were part of my headcanon. Cheers to Telanu! Splendid story!

Name or Alias:	samantha (corky)
Homepage URL:	http://watson-writes-behindthebluedoor.blogspot.com
About general site, or specific page? :	Epistolary Snippet by Predatrix
Comments: more more more :)

Name or Alias:	Shanah
Homepage URL:	http://www.myspace.com/shanaholmes219
About general site, or specific page? :	general
Comments: Hi! Thank you for this site and your fictions! I have read the Wild Reality first here... and I am crying to the end...The feeling is so familiar...the wild reality...

Name or Alias:	Sylkie
About general site, or specific page? :	Sylkie;Experiment;29SEP2010
Comments: Sylkie;Experiment;29SEP2010 Hi...I'm Sylkie. Never been here before. Just wanted to say that "Experiment" is an awesome fic. I love the way it's written. Great job, Miss Roylott! :)

Name or Alias:	Vetesse
Homepage URL:	http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=112176865503396&ref=ts
About general site, or specific page? :	general
Comments: Love your site! It was the first one I ever picked to read when I was just getting into this amazing pairing and it still remains one of my favorite sites. I also wanted to let any fellow Sherlock slashers know that I've started a Facebook group dedicated to this pairing in all of its forms. It's called 'Elementary My Dear Holmes (A Holmes/Watson slash group)' I've been inspired! Thank you much!

Name or Alias:	Kiwi Bird
About general site, or specific page? :	fanfic page
Comments: I was having trouble following links to some of Miss Roylott's fanfic. I could access the first couple of stories but none of the later ones. Are the links broken, or is it just me? Thanks for your help!

Name or Alias:	Ellen
About general site, or specific page? :	general
Comments: Amazing site! Can't wait for more material!

Name or Alias:	Jella Roish
About general site, or specific page? :	Madness
Comments: I love this sketch, and certainly hope you'll continue it. I'm also really glad you looked into asexuality, because it seems more probable that Holmes is just that. (That's always been my opinion anyway.) But, I hope you finish this one. I don't mind the typical "sexual" slash, but much prefer this kind. It is true that some asexuals still feel romantic/emotional love, I'm so glad you pointed this out! And I'm very excited to read about the implications of compromise which, as you said, are a huge obstacle in sexual/asexual pairings. Right now, I love how Holmes is so tender with Watson, it's absolutely endearing. All in all, I really like where this is going, and it serves as a good test for you to write about this topic in this situation (as it is sadly very neglected). I love it though, please continue!

Name or Alias:	Chas
About general site, or specific page? :	general
Comments: Love the site!

Name or Alias:	Lonewolfe001
About general site, or specific page? :	Experiment
Comments: Very HOT and smutty. Poor sherlock he should stop being logical and just feel.

Name or Alias:	Rebecca Wilde
Homepage URL:	http://www.youtube.com/user/rebeccawilde
About general site, or specific page? :	general
Comments: Just wanted to say I love this site! Have had many happy hours of reading through it. ;)

Name or Alias:	Klinsy
About general site, or specific page? :	general
Comments: I love everything you writed!Thank you so much for being so talented,so amazing!Greetings from China.

Name or Alias:	TJaye
About general site, or specific page? :	general
Comments: I'm reading "A Prelude to Partnership" and just wanted to say that I'm enjoying it. Thanx geeminorchord@gmail.com

Name or Alias:	Ryn
About general site, or specific page? :	"Prelude" story
Comments: I would just like to say how well written this fic-series was. At first I was a bit apprehensive when the affair-at-the-university idea was introduced, but the characters were perfectly maintained and I soon began to enjoy the story immensely :) also, must express my glee (!) over a well-done trans character! The problem with trans characters is that they are usually badly done or the focus of the entire fic. That Rose was not really a main theme but still a good character was a pleasant surprise. And you got the pronouns right! Anyway, now I must go away and mourn the fact that I haven't got my own loving Holmes or Watson!

Name or Alias:	Derien
About general site, or specific page? :	Susanna Shepard's "Hidden Depths"
Comments: I've read this before and liked it, but wanted to comment because recent events have given me more of an appreciation for good writing when I see it. This is so solidly good - excellent Watson voice, every detail follows through and keeps the mood perfect. Such a sad ending for Holmes, but, well... they're still friends, which is what counts for him, I think.

Name or Alias:	Obsidianwolf97
About general site, or specific page? :	general
Comments: Well, I must say I was pleasantly surprised when I found this site. I looked a bit ago and couldn't find anything. This is an excellent collection of fics and art. I do have one question. Ever heard of Thundertori, also known as Yayoi Neko? She has some lovely art both on DeviantArt and on Y-Gallery, though you must be a member on Y-Gallery to view her art. She also has a Sherlock Holmes doujinshi she made recently. Hope you find some way to use this information! Thanks again for all the great stuff on the site. I hope to see you updating it in the future.

Name or Alias:	LadyRose
About general site, or specific page? :	general
Comments: Thanks for fixing those links!

About general site, or specific page? :	general
Comments: What a beautiful site. I recently reawakened my love for the stories of Sherlock Holmes and as such Holmes/Watson slash. What a godsend this is!

Name or Alias:	TygerCub
Homepage URL:	http://sites.google.com/site/mindmyway/
About general site, or specific page? :	general
Comments: Love the site. The collection of authors are brilliant and their depictions of the characters are well thought out and lovingly written with sensitivity and style. I am once more drawn into the world of fan fiction and am loving every minute of it! What a wonderful discovery!

Name or Alias:	lettuce
About general site, or specific page? :	general
Comments: i love this site. i think you have converted me to h/w.